Oliver & Co.
Curated Vintage Goods
Curated Vintage Furniture
& Mid-Century Modern Decor
in Southwest Michigan
Hello and welcome to my independently-owned vintage shop located in a historic 1880s general store just outside of Paw Paw, Michigan. Inside you’ll find a rotating collection of carefully curated vintage furniture, mid-century modern pieces, and unique home goods sourced by me and fellow vintage lovers. Each item is chosen for its quality, character, and story — pieces meant to bring personality and warmth into your home.
About Me
I grew up going to yard sales, antique stores, volunteering at thrift stores, and everything in between. Along with a love for vintage and antiques, I strongly believe in reusing, repurposing, and recycling. Bringing new life and purpose to lost and forgotten treasures is very meaningful to me. I also love talking with my clients and connecting them with that special item that brings them joy.
I first officially started selling vintage in 2006 and completed my degree in Sales & Business Marketing in 2010. Over the years I have had vintage items appear in movies, high-end commercials, and most commonly — and my personal favorite — your home!
Home is such a special place — a place surrounded by family and full of memories. I enjoy knowing that I have had a small yet meaningful part in helping make your house a home.
Since starting my online presence in 2006, I’ve sourced vintage items while running stores on eBay, Etsy, and Facebook Marketplace, as well as participating in local antique fairs and markets. Now we have our very own brick & mortar in a late 1800’s general store! I look forward to expanding in the future with markets on our adjacent land and creating opportunities for even more like-minded friends in the business.
Today Oliver & Co. serves vintage lovers throughout Paw Paw, Kalamazoo, and Southwest Michigan, both in our in-person and online shops.
A sincere thank you to my family for their continued support, and to everyone who helps make this possible. I wouldn’t be here without you!
Sarah Kelsey
Owner & Curator
All items are shown as examples of goods.
Featured sale items can be seen online at Instagram, Facebook Marketplace, Etsy, and eBay.
Shop with us!
You can shop my finds at the Storefront just outside of Paw Paw, Michigan during one of the open shopping days. Open days can be found here. The Storefront is also available by appointment for listed furniture items and pick ups of pre-purchased items. I do not offer browsing appointments at this time or drop in’s during unscheduled times.
Curated deals
Click here to browse and view current listings on Facebook Marketplace. You can message me directly through a listing or contact me.
Items can ship nationally and internationally through ebay's international shipping program. Some exclusions may apply.
Click here to visit my eBay storefront and browse current listings. eBay is a large part of my business, and you will find many items there that you won’t normally see in the shop.
I have been on eBay since 2006 and have a lot of experience shipping smalls and listing oddities. Some items are cross-posted as well. If you see something that catches your eye, reach out!
Curated High-End Items
Click here to view my Etsy shop, where I occasionally list a small handful of select items.
If you have any questions about the items listed, feel free to reach out, or you can purchase directly through Etsy to have the item shipped to you (domestically).
Colleen L.
Sarah is great! She provided very detailed information and was quick to answer questions. She made the process so easy and I love my new table and chairs!
Facebook Marketplace
Alexis C.
A wonderful transaction and nice item! Arrived exactly as described with very secure packaging and speedy shipping. Highly recommend Sarah!
eBay Buyer
Karen C.
Best place ever for unique finds! Everything is as she describes! I have no worries buying from photos because I know it will be as she says or better.
Facebook Marketplace
